Alloy Steel Chain versus Wire Rope: Which one to choose?
In lifting, rigging, and securing heavy loads, the choice of equipment will play a key role in ensuring both the safety, efficiency, and reliability of operations. Among the most widely applied in lifting applications are alloy steel chains and wire rope. Each has distinct characteristics that make them appropriate for specific applications, but which to select oftentimes will depend on the nature of work involved, on loadbearing capacity requirements, environmental conditions of the area of use, and factors of safety.
We will compare alloy steel chains and wire rope in this blog, elaborating on the benefits and drawbacks of each one and highlighting their applications. By the end of this blog post, you will know more about the differences between these two popular mediums for lifting and be able to choose the right one for your needs.
But first, let’s define in simple terms what each of these materials is and how they are used in a lifting operation.
Alloy Steel Chains
Alloy steel chains are high strength chains made from steel alloys containing chromium, molybdenum, nickel, and vanadium. It makes the steel alloy tougher and harder. They resist fatigue and wear down, making them last longer. In simple words, they keep the chain more durable and reliable. Most of these chains are used where chain applications are meant for longdurable types of lifting, hoisting, and securing loads.
These chains are often used in the rigging systems, overhead cranes, hoists, and towing operations industries and can be applied in the construction, maritime, and oil and gas.
Wire Rope
A wire rope consists of various steel wires twisted together to make one single, strong yet flexible rope. These individual wires often have a coating made from galvanized steel or polymer coatings to give resistance to corrosion and wear and tear. The process of building wire rope usually takes on a specific form called laying, whereby wires are wrapped onto a core, usually from steel or fiber, to produce a flexible and resilient rope that bears heavy loads with much flexibility.
Wire rope is used in cranes, elevators, winches, marine operations, mining, among countless other uses.
Alloy Steel Chains vs. Wire Rope
Both alloy steel chains and wire rope are significant in lifting and securing operations, but each has its advantages and disadvantages, making them suitable for particular types of work. Let’s get a closer look into the key aspects of each:
-
Strength and Load Capacity
Alloy Steel Chains: Extremely high tensile strength and loadbearing capacity make alloy steel chains excel. Excellent alloy steel allows the chains to carry exceptionally heavy loads without being twisted or deformed. Alloy chains exhibit great strength in shear strength or resisting the action of cutting or deformation due to applied load, thereby making them suitable for applications which require direct and vertical lifting. Their breaking strength is also said to be relatively greater than that of wire rope in most extreme lifting tasks.
Wire Rope: This type is also very strong and can lift heavy loads as well, though it is not typically as strong in shear strength as alloy steel chains. However, it is great in flexibility and bending strength so that it can easily be suited for dynamic, curved, or angled loads. The rope often outperforms alloy steel chains in durability where the rope is pulled, twisted, or bent for those applications.
Conclusion: If a system is required to be geared to vertical direct lifting with a high load capacity, then the choice of alloy steel chains often is better. However, if one requires dynamics while lifting or pulling or just the system requires some flexibility, then wire rope may be the better answer.
Durability and LongTerm Use
Alloy Steel Chains
These are very durable, especially in static load applications. Alloy steel chains do not wear much since they are rigidly constructed, especially for applications of constant tension or lift. In load cases, there is minimal stretching or deformation, maintaining their form even after a long period of time.
Wire Rope: Wire rope is also very strong but will wear faster than alloy steel chains under certain conditions. The two major challenges with wire rope are friction between the individual wires that causes these wires to be rubbed out, and the possibility of the rope to kink or twist in use. Over time wire rope may suffer a loss in strength from fatigue or by snapping the interior wires. Although the wire rope is designed to take bending, its versatility also makes it more prone to abrasion where there might be stiff surfaces or harsh environments.
Conclusion: Alloy steel chains are quite more resistant to static loads and will also provide a longer service life, particularly with static loads. In contrast, the versatility of the wire rope allows it to have applications with dynamic forces but may tend to wear more easily with harsh conditions.
-
Flexibility and Versatility
Alloy Steel Chains: Alloy steel chains do not flex and are to be used only where the chain is straight and taut. They are best used on single lifting points or rigging systems where there is little need for great deflection or bending. They are wellsuited for situations with overhead cranes, hoisting, and lifting where the load path is direct, and little fluctuation is met.
The advantages of wire rope are many, but one major advantage is in its flexibility: a wire rope can be bent over pulleys, winches, and drums without losing its strength and performance. Therefore, it is the only practicable option for applications where the rope has to pass through a complicated system or over multiple pulleys or drums. Wire rope is applied for handling moving, twisting, or bending dynamic loads. It is versatile in such applications as marine, mining, and elevating systems.
Conclusion: In the event of a flexible application, an individual is advised to choose wire rope. If the application requires much rigging, pulleys, and dynamic movement, then that is the best cable.
-
Weight and Storage
The weight of alloy steel chain is the main disadvantage; they weigh more than wire ropes, which creates immense difficulties in handling, especially if the chain has been used for lifting activities and should be shifted or stored. Any additional rigidity of the chain complicates the management of the chain, particularly in storage or multiple chain usage.
Wire Rope: Much lighter than alloy steel chains, wire rope is easier to store and deploy. It might be wound or coiled in drums for easy transport and storing. Although lighter and not as strong as alloy steel chains concerning loadcarrying capacity, its weight can make it easier when dynamic or frequent use situations are encountered.
Verdict: the wire ropes are better for applications where weights and storage space efficiencies are more critical whereas alloy steel chains are heavier and provide unmatched strength.
-
Corrosion Resistance
Alloy Steel Chains: Alloy steel chains, plated with galvanization or other protective plating, are fair corrosionresistance materials. However, they don’t provide as great resistance to corrosion as stainless steel or other corrosionresistant materials used in wire rope. Therefore, alloy steel chains would need to be serviced frequently to remove rust and corrosion buildup should they be employed in mariner or offshore applications.
Wire Rope: The wire rope must be stainless steel or coated with galvanized steel so as to provide corrosion resistance. That is the reason why wire rope is used in applications that are marine or offshore applications, likely to be exposed to moisture and saltwater or corrosive elements.
Conclusion: For applications that involve moisture or harsh environments, alloy steel or galvanized material for wire rope is preferred over chain because of the excellent corrosion protection afforded by such products.
Applications of Alloy Steel Chains vs. Wire Rope
Alloy steel chains and wire ropes are applied in two different applications due to specific characteristics:
Alloy Steel Chains:
Heavy lifts construction, mining, industrial lift
Fixed rigging systems overhead cranes, hoists
Towing and securing loads
Forged applications that require rigid connection
Wire Rope:
Marine operations (such as ship rigging, offshore platforms)
Cranes and winches (where flexibility is needed)
Elevators, and elevating systems
Rigging in dynamic systems (such as pulleys and drums)
Conclusion: Which is Best?
Alloy steel chains and wire rope have unique benefits each of which is applied in different lifting and rigging applications.
Alloy steel chains are very good at strength and are much tougher, and used mainly in direct vertical lifts or for extremely heavyduty applications where there are static loads coming into play.
Wire rope is applied specifically where there are concerns related to flexibility, dynamic loads, and especially corrosionresistant properties; it is applied mainly to marine or offshore uses, complex rigging systems with pulleys and winches.
Ultimately, the choice between alloy steel chains and wire rope will depend upon the specific requirements of your lifting or rigging operation, which may include the load capacity, environmental conditions, flexibility, and handling ease. You will know exactly which is best suited for your needs by understanding the strengths and limitations of each material.